The Revealer
A daily review of religion and the press

home
aboutus
archive
links


The Rebellion Within
31 May 2008
"The Rebellion Within," Lawrence Wright's long New Yorker account of theological rifts between leading Islamist militants, defies easy summary. That's because Wright' story is a story, not a thesis or a set of talking points backed up by illustration. That won't stop some readers from responding to the weakest line in this otherwise brilliant piece of reporting: "...rumors that imprisoned leaders of Al Jihad were part of a trend in which former terrorists renounced violence." Trends, rumours, and renunciation. That's the cliff's notes version. Don't cheat yourself -- read the whole thing, an engrossing and important work of intellectual history, not a trend report. That's right -- "intellectual history," often (but not often enough) the most revealing kind of reporting.

Letters to the Editor


The Revealer © 2005       Contact: the.revealer@nyu.edu       Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use       Syndicate This Site: RSS 1 RSS 2       Powered by Movable Type